Jack Pelletier, 264

Jack Pelletier, a Government major, walked into the house at auditions and belted out Elvis Presley's "Can't Help Falling in Love with You," and indeed we couldn't.  Jack comes to us from...well it's complicated.  He lives in San Francisco, but talk to him for more than five seconds and you'll hear the New England prep school in him.  When Jack isn't savoring all of his baritone parries, you can find him crying tears of joy while watching Larry Bird highlights or cooking up massive amounts of mac and cheese

Superlative: Most likely to slip into a Boston accent when talking about his Lord and Savior, Tom Brady